South Korean Court Exonerates Bitcoiner Who Received BTC 200 by Mistake

A bitcoin (BTC) wallet owner who received almost BTC 200 (USD 4.16m) by accident has been absolved of blame by a branch of the South Korean High Court, which overturned two previous rulings in doing so.

2
Supreme Court of Korea

The court heard that in June 2018, A received a deposit of BTC 199.999 from another individual (named by the court as “B”). B appears to have sent the funds by accident – and likely made a mistake when typing the recipient’s address.

A, however, appears to have made no attempt to return the funds or try to discover who had sent the bitcoin. Instead, A proceeded to transfer the coins to two wallets also held in A’s name.

At the original trial, A was found guilty of “breach of trust” violations, with the judge stating that A had been in the position to “safeguard the incorrectly remitted bitcoin” according to “principles of good faith” – but had instead “violated” these principles. The judge in the first trial had ruled that A had “taken advantage” of the error in an “illegal” manner.

A second court upheld this verdict, but the Supreme Court ruled that a third trial should be held, and at that point temporarily overturned the original sentence pending a third trial.

The Supreme Court stated that “a person who has received an erroneous transfer of cryptoassets may be obliged to return [funds they obtained] in an unreasonable manner.” But, it stated, this case was “nothing more than a civil debt” between “two individuals.”

The High Court, meanwhile, added that the South Korean law did not include “stipulations for criminal punishment” in the case of an individual who receives cryptoassets without knowing how these coins appeared in their wallet.

The judge explained:

“It goes against the principle of the criminal justice system to punish a person for breach of trust in this instance.”

A regulatory financial tribunal, which presented evidence at the trial, was quoted as explaining:

“According to the relevant laws, cryptoassets are not subject to the same rules as fiat currency. As such, the laws that apply to fiat do not apply [to cryptoassets]. Cryptoassets does not have to be protected in the same way.”

Tim Alper(2022.06.21) South Korean Court Exonerates Bitcoiner Who Received BTC 200 by Mistake
retrieved from https://cryptonews.com/news/south-korean-court-exonerates-bitcoiner-who-received-btc-200-by-mistake.htm

2 COMMENTS

  1. CRYPTO RECOVERY IS REAL!!!

    ( Morris Gray 830 At gmail Dot Com, is the man for the job ) This man is dedicated to his work and you can trust him more than yourself. I contacted him a year and a half Ago and he didn’t succeed. when i got ripped of $491,000 worth of bitcoins by scammers, I tried several recovery programs with no success too. I kept on. And now after so much time Mr Morris Gray contacted me with a success, and the reward he took was small because obviously he is doing this because he wants to help idiots like me who fell for crypto scam, and love his job. Of course he could have taken all the coins and not tell me , I was not syncing this wallet for a year, but he didn’t. He is the MAN guys , He is! If you have been a victim of crypto scam before you can trust Morris Gray 10000000%. I thought there were no such good genuine guys anymore on earth, but Mr Morris Gray brought my trust to humanity again. GOD bless you sir…you can reach him via ( MORRIS GRAY 830 at Gmail dot com ) or Whatsapp +1 (607)698-0239..

  2. We kunnen u ook helpen uw verlopen Belgisch rijbewijs binnen drie tot vijf dagen zonder stress te vernieuwen. Ook kunnen we een buitenlander helpen om binnen een week een buitenlands rijbewijs om te wisselen naar een Belgisch. Neem nu contact met ons op om hulp te krijgen.
    Whatsapp-nummer:+32 460 24 65 88
    https://www.echt-rijbewijs.com/

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here